
Home Insurance in Columbus
Columbus, Ohio, isn't just the state capital; it's one of the fastest-growing cities in the Midwest. With a population nearing a million and a booming tech and healthcare scene, it's easy to see why more people are choosing to call Columbus home.
Whether you're setting up in Victorian Village, Clintonville, or out in the suburbs of Hilliard or Dublin, one thing remains true: Buckeye weather could be unpredictable. From freezing winter storms that crack pipes to spring hail and summer tornado watches, Ohio throws the whole weather playbook at homeowners.
That's where homeowners insurance in Columbus, OH, comes in. With the right coverage, your home could be protected from the unexpected.
How much is the average homeowner's insurance in Columbus, Ohio?
Home insurance rates in Columbus, while not the cheapest in the Buckeye State, are relatively affordable. The average cost of home insurance in Columbus is $1,610 per year [1], which is significantly lower than the national average.
Curious about Ohio's average home insurance costs over the past five years? The table below shows statewide yearly averages, not specific to Columbus or any other city.
Keep in mind, these are statewide figures. Your rate might vary based on where you live. Factors like home value, local weather, and population could affect your premium.
Year | Average Annual Premium [2] |
---|---|
2025 | $1,590 |
2024 | $1,236 |
2023 | $1,600 |
2022 | $1,224 |
2021 | $920 |
What factors influence home insurance rates?
Like Columbus neighborhoods, no two policies are exactly the same. Several factors could influence how much you pay for home insurance quotes in Columbus:
- Location: Where your home is located is one of the biggest influences on your insurance cost. If you live in an area that's prone to natural disasters like floods or hurricanes, or one with a higher crime rate, you could expect to pay more for coverage in Columbus.
- Home value: Your home's value matters because it determines how much it would cost to rebuild if it's completely damaged. Insurance providers often check the home's purchase price and appraisal to set coverage limits.
- Home features: Certain features make your house riskier to insure. For example, if you have a swimming pool or trampoline, your premium will likely be higher due to the increased risk of injury. Outdated electrical, plumbing, or heating systems could also raise your rate because they're more likely to cause damage.
- Claims history: A clean claims history could save you money. Insurers reward customers who haven't filed many claims, often with discounts. On the flip side, having multiple past claims could lead to higher rates. Many home insurance companies in Ohio use a CLUE report to check your home and auto claims from the last seven years.
- Coverage amount: The coverage amount you choose could also affect your premium. If you want a higher coverage limit to fully protect your home and belongings, you'll pay more. However, this additional cost gives you peace of mind that you're better protected in case of a total loss.
Common insurance discounts in Columbus
If you’d like to decrease your Columbus homeowners’ insurance premium, there are a few things that you could do without cutting coverage.
Many insurance companies often offer discounts that could make your policy more affordable. From bundling policies to making eco-friendly upgrades, here are some common discounts you might qualify for:
- Multi-policy discount: If your insurance company provides more than just homeowners insurance, like auto or renters insurance, you could save by bundling. Buying multiple policies from the same company usually earns you a multi-policy discount.
- Loyalty discount: Some insurance carriers reward homeowners who stay with them for a long period of time. The longer you stick with them, the more you might save. However, note that loyalty doesn't always mean the best deal. It's better to compare Columbus homeowners insurance costs every year to make sure you’re still getting the best price.
- Advance quote discount: Often, homeowners in Columbus could get a discount if they plan ahead. Many insurance companies will reduce your premium if you request home insurance quotes in Columbus, Ohio one or two weeks before you need the policy to start. This is known as an advance quote discount, and it's an easy way to save.
- ● New home discount: If your home was built recently, you might qualify for a new home discount. Newer homes are usually built to modern safety codes, which makes them less likely to have costly damage. Most insurers consider a home "new" if it's less than 10 years old.
- Green home discount: Eco-friendly houses could also qualify for savings. If your home or property has Energy Star-rated appliances, is LEED-certified, or includes other sustainable features, you might earn a green home discount. These upgrades not only help the planet, but they could also reduce your insurance premiums.
Not every insurance company in Columbus, offers every discount, so it's worth comparing multiple home insurance quotes, before locking in your policy coverage.
What does home insurance in Columbus typically cover?
A standard homeowners insurance policy in Columbus – also called an HO-3 policy – provides a broad range of protection for your home and personal belongings. It typically covers damage to your home's structure, your personal items, and more.
While Columbus property insurance is not required by law, mortgage lenders typically require it to protect the home. Here's what homeowners insurance in Columbus usually covers:
- Dwelling coverage: Dwelling coverage is the core of your home insurance policy. It pays to repair, rebuild, or replace your home if it's damaged by a covered loss. This might include things like fire, vandalism, theft, or severe weather (such as wind, hail, or lightning). It could also cover damage caused by outside forces, such as a falling tree branch.
- Personal property coverage: This policy covers personal belongings inside your home. It includes furniture, clothing, appliances, and your heating or cooling systems. If you own expensive items such as jewelry, fine art, or collectibles, you might need to purchase extra coverage to fully protect them.
- Other structures: Detached structures on your property – like a garage, shed, barn, outdoor fireplace, fence, swing set, or wall – are also covered. Recreational items, such as trampolines or swimming pools, might also be included. However, because they pose a higher risk, you might need additional liability coverage.
- Loss of use: If your home becomes unlivable due to a covered event, loss of use coverage could help pay for temporary living expenses. This could include hotel stays, restaurant meals, or parking fees. Keep in mind that policies have set limits and timeframes, so check your policy details to know what's covered.
- Personal liability coverage: Liability coverage helps protect you financially if someone is injured on your property and decides to sue. It could help pay for legal costs, settlements, and medical expenses.
Additional Columbus insurance coverage options
Standard coverage could be a good start; however, there are gaps you might want to fill, especially in a city that experiences a range of weather conditions.
Here are a few add-ons you might want to consider:
- Flood insurance: Columbus sits at the confluence of the Scioto and Olentangy Rivers. If you're near a floodplain or low-lying area, you may want to look into a separate flood insurance policy (available through FEMA or private providers).
- Sewer or water backup: This add-on coverage protects you if sewage or water backs up into your home or if your sump pump overflows. It could help cover the cost of cleaning up and repairing damage, including repairs to the sewer line within your property boundaries.
- Mold coverage: Ohio humidity and wet basements could lead to mold, which isn't always covered in standard policies. A mold endorsement might be worth the extra cost.
- Equipment breakdown: This insurance policy covers major appliances and systems, such as your HVAC, refrigerator, or water heater, if they break down — think of it as a home warranty built into your insurance.
- Identity theft protection: Columbus has a growing population of remote workers. If you do a lot of online activities, this optional coverage could help protect your identity by providing monitoring services and support with restoration efforts after a breach.
What Columbus residents need to know
If you own a house or other property in Columbus, Ohio, your job doesn't end at just buying a policy. Here's what to look out for:
- Don't under-insure your home: With rising construction costs across Central Ohio, ensure your policy's dwelling limit reflects today's rebuilding rates, not last year's market value.
- Schedule high-value items: Items such as heirloom jewelry, camera equipment, or vintage collectibles might need separate scheduling to be fully covered.
- Check your wind/hail deductible: In Ohio, some policies split wind and hail into a separate deductible. Know what yours is before storm season.
- Struggling to find coverage: The Ohio FAIR Plan could help if your home is considered high-risk and private insurers won't cover it.
How to lower your Columbus home insurance premium
Living in Columbus means enjoying a mix of urban amenities, historic charm, and Midwestern affordability. However, who doesn't want to save more?
Try these actionable strategies:
- Perform regular maintenance: A home that's in good shape is less likely to have claims, and that keeps your premiums in check. If you've got a musty basement in Worthington or worn-out wiring in a 1920s Short North bungalow, tackle those projects now before they turn into expensive problems. Simple fixes, like sealing foundation cracks, cleaning gutters, or replacing old pipes, show your insurance company that you're proactive. And that could go a long way in reducing your risk profile.
- Don't just auto-renew; shop around: It's easy to let your policy auto-renew every year, but that could cost you. Instead, obtain at least three quotes when your renewal date approaches. Different insurers weigh things such as Columbus ZIP codes, proximity to a fire station, or your home's age in different ways, so shopping around could reveal a lower rate for the same (or better) coverage.
- Skip small claims when you could: Yes, home insurance could help, but not every problem needs to be filed. If your fence gets damaged in a windstorm or a window breaks during a backyard soccer match, it might be cheaper in the long run to pay out of pocket. Filing multiple small claims could flag you as a higher risk, which might lead to premium increases or even non-renewal. Save your coverage for the bigger stuff, like a kitchen fire or severe water damage, and handle the little things on your own when possible.
Still have questions?
What salary do you need to live comfortably in Columbus?
To live comfortably in Columbus, a single person typically requires an annual salary of $96,500 after taxes, depending on lifestyle and housing choices. For a family of four, the comfort range increases to $235,000 annually. These figures account for housing, transportation, healthcare, food, and modest savings. Keep in mind that home insurance is just one part of the total monthly housing cost.
How much is the property tax in Columbus?
In Columbus, property tax rates vary based on the school district and exact location. However, the average effective property tax rate in Franklin County is approximately 1.86%, which is slightly higher than the national average. Property taxes are a significant factor in calculating overall homeownership costs, alongside house insurance premiums.
Sources
1 Information from NerdWallet.
2 Information from Ohio Department of Insurance,Quote Wizard,Truehold,Policygenius, and NerdWallet.
This article is for informational purposes only and was compiled from sources not affiliated with Hippo. While we believe this information to be reliable, we do not guarantee its accuracy or completeness. For any insurance-related decision, please consult your licensed insurance producer.